Review of the Private Full-Day Walking Tour in Edinburgh with Edinburgh Castle
If you’re visiting Edinburgh for the first time and want to see the highlights without the hassle of planning every detail, a private full-day walking tour is an excellent choice. Priced at around $430 per person, this tour offers roughly 7 hours of exploring the city’s best-loved sights with the convenience of a dedicated guide. The itinerary covers iconic landmarks like Edinburgh Castle, the Royal Mile, and the trendy Victoria Street, with plenty of time to soak in the atmosphere and take photos.
What impresses me most about this experience are two things: the personalized attention from your guide and the chance to move at your own pace. With a private tour, there’s no rushing through sites or feeling lost in a crowd. And from the glowing reviews, guides like Susan and Fraser seem to genuinely enjoy customizing the day to match your interests — whether you’re a history lover or just eager to see the city’s most photogenic spots.
One consideration is the price point, which might seem high at first glance. But when you factor in the included Edinburgh Castle tickets, the tailored experience, and how much you’ll learn and see in a single day, the value becomes clearer. Remember, this isn’t a generic group tour — it’s tailored for your group, making all the difference for a memorable, stress-free day.
Key Points

- Personalized Experience: A private guide makes all the difference in customizing your day.
- Coverage of Major Sites: From Edinburgh Castle to the Royal Mile, every highlight is included.
- Flexibility: The pace is suited to your group, allowing more time for favorite sites and photos.
- Incredible Views: Stops like Calton Hill offer some of the best panoramic city vistas.
- Expert Guidance: Guides like Susan and Fraser are praised for their knowledge and engaging personalities.
- Value for Money: Combining private attention, tickets, and insider tips makes this a worthwhile splurge.
Exploring the Itinerary in Detail

The tour kicks off at Howies Restaurant, conveniently located at Waterloo Place, giving you a scenic starting point right in the heart of the city. Your guide will escort you along the Royal Mile, the cobbled street that’s lined with shops, historic sites, and atmospheric alleys. Expect to hear fascinating stories and get insider tips as you walk this legendary thoroughfare — a highlight loved by many, with one reviewer noting that it’s a great way to get a feel for Edinburgh’s character.
Next, you’ll ascend Calton Hill, famous for its punchy collection of monuments and breathtaking views. Many guides use this as a photo opportunity and a moment to reflect on Edinburgh’s history. You’ll spend about 30 minutes here, enjoying the skyline that includes famous landmarks like the National Monument and Nelson’s Monument.
The New Town section offers a contrast with its elegant neoclassical architecture, charming streets, and the perfect backdrop for those Instagram photos. Spending time in Princes Street Gardens allows for a leisurely stroll amidst lush greenery with the castle towering in the background — all great spots for photos and deep breaths.
Your guide might take you through the aristocratic Heriot Row and Charlotte Square, UNESCO World Heritage sites known for their beautiful Georgian architecture. Walking through these areas provides a glimpse into Edinburgh’s refined past, with the option to admire the gardens and historic buildings at a relaxed pace. Many reviews mention guides like Martin, who are praised for their local knowledge and ability to adapt the tour to guests’ interests.
A stop at St Giles’ Cathedral is a must — your guide will share stories about the church’s significance, the famous Dome Restaurant, and the role this site played in Scottish history. Walking through the Grassmarket district offers a chance for lunch (at your own expense), in a lively area known for its pubs and historic ambiance. This break is well-timed, giving you a chance to absorb the local atmosphere.
The highlight of the day is visiting Edinburgh Castle, where your ticket is included. Expect about 45 minutes to explore both the castle’s impressive grounds and learn about its tumultuous past, including its medieval battles and royal connections. Many visitors, like Chris and others, find this a real highlight, describing it as a “wonderful” experience.
Following the castle, your tour might take you along Victoria Street, famous for its colorful shops and Harry Potter lore, offering plenty of photo opportunities. You’ll also walk past the John Knox House and Palace of Holyroodhouse, where some parts are not included in the ticket but still provide fascinating sights and stories about Scotland’s religious and royal history.
The tour ends near Holyrood Palace, with your guide ready to assist in navigating public transportation or taxis back to your accommodation. The flexibility to end the tour here is especially appreciated, as it saves you the effort of returning to your hotel.
Want to keep it personal? More private experiences we love in Edinburgh
The Practical Side and Why It Matters
A major benefit of this tour is the inclusion of Edinburgh Castle tickets, which alone can be pricey and sometimes hard to get on your own. Coupled with the guide’s expert commentary, it makes the entire day feel more enriching. The private group aspect means you won’t be held up by large crowds or rushed through sites, giving you the freedom to linger or skip certain parts.
While lunch and transportation costs are not included, the guide’s recommendations for where to eat and how to get around are valuable. Plus, with plenty of time for photos and questions, you can truly personalize your experience. Many reviewers appreciate guides like Susan, Paul, Rafal, and Fraser — highly praised for their knowledge and friendly approach.
The 7-hour duration ensures you see a broad swath of Edinburgh without feeling overwhelmed. This is perfect for travelers who want a rundown but still enjoy a relaxed pace. The group discounts and mobile tickets add convenience, and booking well in advance (around 57 days) suggests a popular experience.
Who Should Consider This Tour?

Ideal for first-time visitors who want the comfort of a private guide to navigate the city’s highlights, especially if you value personalized recommendations. It’s also great for history enthusiasts looking for deeper insights, as well as those who prefer to avoid the uncertainty of public tours. Plus, if you’re traveling with family or a small group, the tailored approach ensures everyone’s interests are covered.
However, if you’re on a tight budget or prefer self-guided exploring, this may feel pricey. Also, travelers should have moderate physical fitness, as the tour involves walking and some uphill walking, particularly when visiting sites like Calton Hill and Edinburgh Castle.
Final Thoughts: Is This Tour Worth It?

In a city as captivating as Edinburgh, a private full-day tour offers an unbeatable way to experience the highlights without the stress. You’ll appreciate the knowledgeable guides, whether it’s Susan’s friendly approach or Fraser’s passion for Edinburgh’s stories, along with the stunning vistas from Calton Hill and the grandeur of Edinburgh Castle.
For those who crave a personalized experience, the flexibility to choose how much time to spend at each site, and insider tips on dining and other attractions, this tour is a fine choice. While it’s more expensive than group options, the value lies in the tailored attention, included castle tickets, and the chance to see the city through your guide’s eyes.
This experience is most suited for travelers seeking comfort and detailed insight, especially first-timers eager to get a comprehensive, yet relaxed, introduction to Edinburgh. If you’re after a deep dive into the city’s stories, this tour will leave you with plenty of memorable sights and personal recommendations for the rest of your stay.
FAQ

Is this tour suitable for all fitness levels?
Yes, but keep in mind you’ll be walking, including some uphill sections like Calton Hill. Moderate physical fitness is recommended.
Does the tour include transportation?
No, this is a walking tour, and transportation costs are not included. The guide will advise on public transit options at the end.
How long does the visit to Edinburgh Castle last?
About 45 minutes, giving you time to explore the grounds and absorb the history, with your included ticket.
Can I customize the itinerary?
Since it’s a private tour, your guide can adapt the day to your interests and pace, within the scheduled stops.
Are food and drinks included?
No, meals are at your own expense, but the guide can recommend lunch spots, especially in the lively Grassmarket area.
How far in advance should I book?
Most bookings are made around 57 days in advance, but availability can vary during peak seasons.
This private Edinburgh tour aims to combine the ease of expert guidance with the thrill of discovering one of Europe’s most captivating cities. Whether it’s your first visit or a return trip, this experience offers a well-balanced, engaging way to explore the best of Edinburgh.
If you're enjoying exploring Edinburgh on foot, you'll love these other walking tours we recommend
More Walking Tours in Edinburgh
More Tours in Edinburgh
More Tour Reviews in Edinburgh
Not for you? Here's more things to do in Edinburgh we have recnetly reviewed
- Magic and Legends in Edinburgh: walking tour in French
- From Edinburgh: Glenfinnan Viaduct & The Highlands Day Trip
- From Edinburgh: Loch Ness, Glencoe, and the Highlands Tour
- Tour of Outlander In Edinburgh
- Edinburgh: Harry Potter and English Castles Tour in Spanish
- Edinburgh: 7 Bar Pub Crawl with 7 Shots & Discounts
- Skip-the-line Edinburgh Castle with Old Town Walking Tour
- Outlander’s Scotland Tour
- Edinburgh: Castle, Holyrood & Royal Mile Guided Tour
- Ghost Tour in Edinburgh
- From Edinburgh: Isle of Skye & Highlands 3-Day Guided Tour
- Islander® Harris Tweed® Mini Satchel Canongate Workshop
