A Taste of Tuscany’s Olive Oil Heritage: A Review of the Mill and EVO Oil Tasting Tour
If you’re heading to Tuscany and want a genuine, hands-on experience in one of Italy’s most iconic products, this tour offers a perfect blend of education, tasting, and local conviviality. For around $33, you’ll spend about an hour exploring the olive oil production process at L’enoteca del Frantoio di Tistarelli Fausta, a family-run mill just outside Sarteano. What makes this tour stand out is its focus on demystifying the process from olive harvest to bottling, with friendly guides and a relaxed atmosphere.
Two things I particularly appreciate are the personalized approach — with the owners and staff sharing their expertise directly — and the delicious tasting session that follows. The oils are presented with clear instructions, and you get to sample them with local bread and tapas, making the experience both fun and flavorful. One potential consideration is that this experience is quite intimate, with a maximum group size of 20, so if you’re looking for a large, bustling tour, this might feel more relaxed than some travelers prefer.
This tour offers fantastic value, especially given the quality of the olive oils, wines, and local delicacies you can buy afterward. It’s a perfect stop for anyone curious about authentic Tuscan food production or looking to deepen their appreciation for Italy’s culinary traditions. Plus, the fact that it’s booked on average 23 days in advance indicates how popular and well-regarded it is among travelers seeking genuine experiences.
Key Points / Takeaways

- Authentic Production Insight: You get a clear view of the traditional and modern methods used to create high-quality extra virgin olive oil.
- Personalized Guides: The owners and staff are eager to explain and share their passion, making the visit both educational and warm.
- Tasting and Food Pairings: The oils are sampled on bruschetta, with local cured meats, pecorino, and fresh tomatoes, enhancing the flavors.
- Local Retail Offerings: You can buy not only EVO oils but also other regional products like wines, honey, and cured meats.
- Small Group Atmosphere: With a maximum of 20 travelers, it’s an intimate experience, ideal for personal interaction.
- Convenient Mobile Ticket & Near Public Transit: Easy booking and accessible location make this a practical choice for many travelers.
Exploring the Mill and EVO Oil Tasting Experience in Detail

Taste buds happy? More delicious discoveries we love in Tuscany
The Joy of Learning How Authentic Olive Oil Is Made
The visit begins at L’enoteca del Frantoio di Tistarelli Fausta, located just outside Sarteano. When I think about olive oil in Tuscany, I usually picture picturesque groves, but this tour takes you behind the scenes to see how the olive harvest turns into that fragrant, flavorful oil we love. The owners and staff use a mix of traditional and innovative techniques, and their explanations are clear and engaging.
While some tours merely showcase a static process, this one emphasizes education—from explaining how olives are picked to the pressing methods that determine oil quality. Expect to see audio-visual materials that help clarify the process, making complex steps accessible. The guide’s enthusiasm is contagious, and I found myself appreciating the care and craftsmanship that goes into each bottle.
The Tasting and Food Pairings
After the mill tour, the real highlight begins—savoring the extra virgin olive oils. Guided by the millers’ instructions, I learned how to distinguish different flavors and aromas—some grassy, others more pungent or fruity. The oils are served with crusty Tuscan bread, and the accompanying local tapas—like bruschetta with fresh tomatoes, cold cuts, and pecorino di Pienza—perfectly complemented the oils.
This part of the experience is relaxed and convivial. As one of the reviewers, Brent, noted, “Staff made us feel so welcome,” and that warm welcome makes tasting even more enjoyable. The oils are not just samples but a way to appreciate the varieties and qualities of Tuscan EVOO.
The Opportunity to Shop
Post-tasting, you’ll have the chance to purchase oils and regional products. This isn’t just a souvenir shop—these are high-quality, authentic regional goods that support local producers. You might find a bottle of olive oil that fits perfectly into your kitchen or gifts for friends back home. The selection includes wines, pecorino, honey, and cured meats, making it a worthwhile stop if you want to bring a taste of Tuscany home.
Group Size and Logistics
With a maximum of 20 travelers, this is a small-group tour, which I think enhances the experience. You won’t feel rushed, and you get plenty of opportunities to ask questions. The tour lasts about 30 minutes, but the entire experience, including tasting and shopping, can extend to an hour or more, depending on your pace.
The mobile ticket makes booking straightforward, and the location near public transport makes it accessible for most visitors. The tour starts at Viale Europa in Sarteano and ends right back there, making it easy to incorporate into a day of exploring Tuscany.
Value for Money
At just over $33, the cost is very reasonable given what you get. The quality of the oils, the personalized attention, and the chance to learn about an essential Tuscan product—all these factors add up to excellent value. Plus, you leave with a better understanding and appreciation of what makes Tuscan olive oil special, not just a souvenir to bring home.
Who Will Love This Tour?
This experience is ideal for food lovers, curious travelers, and anyone interested in authentic local traditions. If you’re hoping for a lively, large-group experience with lots of bells and whistles, this may feel a bit subdued, but for those who want intimacy and depth, it’s perfect. It’s especially suited for those who enjoy tasting and learning in a relaxed environment.
Final Thoughts

This olive oil mill visit offers more than just a tasting; it’s a chance to understand and appreciate the craftsmanship behind Tuscany’s most famous culinary treasure. You’ll leave with new knowledge, delicious oils, and a sense of connection to local producers. The guides are friendly and eager to share their passion, making this experience feel genuine and personal.
The combination of educational value, tasty food, and regional shopping makes it a well-rounded activity that can enhance any Tuscany itinerary. Whether you’re a foodie, a curious traveler, or someone looking for a peaceful, authentic experience, this tour delivers on all fronts.
In the end, this is a wonderful way to spend an hour in Tuscany, gaining insight, enjoying regional flavors, and supporting local artisans. It’s not just a tour—it’s a small slice of Tuscan life that you’ll fondly remember.
FAQ
Is this tour suitable for children or families?
Yes, most travelers can participate, and the relaxed pace makes it suitable for families. Just note that the focus is on learning about olive oil and sampling, so very young children may have limited interest.
How long does the tour last?
The guided mill visit is about 30 minutes, with additional time for tasting and shopping, bringing the total experience to roughly an hour.
Can I buy products after the tour?
Absolutely. You’ll have the opportunity to purchase EVO oils, wines, pecorino, honey, and cured meats directly from the mill.
Is transportation included?
Transportation is not provided, but the tour starts at a convenient location near public transit, making it easy to reach.
Are the oils gluten-free or suitable for dietary restrictions?
While the oils themselves are naturally gluten-free, the tastings include local bread and snacks. If you have dietary restrictions, it’s worth asking in advance.
What’s the best time to book?
Since the tour is often booked 23 days in advance, it’s wise to reserve early, especially in peak travel seasons.
Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, the tour offers free cancellation up to 24 hours before the scheduled start, allowing flexibility if your plans shift.
This tour is a real gem for those eager to connect with authentic Tuscan flavors and traditions. It’s a small but meaningful window into the world of olive oil—delicious, educational, and welcoming—a perfect pause in your Tuscan adventure.
More Tours in Tuscany
- Exclusive Private Half Day Shore Excursion from Livorno port to Pisa
- Montepulciano Pienza Montalcino Tour from Siena
- Private Boat Tour to Cala Violina and the Tuscan coast
- All Tuscany Private Siena San Gimignano & Chianti Livorno Shore Excursion
- Exclusive Private Shore Excursion from Livorno port to Cinque Terre
- Valdorcia & Brunello Ebike Experience Tour
More Tour Reviews in Tuscany
- Wine tasting and guided tour of the cellar
- House of the Butterflies of the Collodi Pinocchio Polycentric Park
- Daily excursions and guaranteed fun in Argentario
- The foody village and the ancient castle
- Private Home-Made Pasta Cooking Class in Pisa.
- Dining experience at a local’s home in Massarosa with cooking demo
Not for you? Here's more things to do in Tuscany we have recnetly reviewed
- From Florence: Tuscany by E-Bike with Lunch and Wine Tasting
- Tuscany:Make your own weddingrings in an unforgettable class
- Horse Riding in Tuscany for Experienced Riders: Full-day Trail Ride
- Siena: Organic Cooking Class & Tastings
- Tuscany: Cake and Biscuit Cooking Class for Kids
- Tuscany: Ripalte Design Winery Wine and Cheese Tasting Tour
- La Maliosa Farm Experience & Wine Tasting
- Tuscany: Sanctuary of La Verna Day Tour Private Tour
- Wild Canyoning
- Pisa and Wine Tasting in Tuscany from Livorno
- Stellar PicNic: Delight at sunset in the Tuscan countryside
- Adrenaline kayaking on the Lima and Serchio rivers in Bagni di Lucca
