Tasting of the Best Wines in Siena in an Etruscan Crypt

This experience offers something quite different from your typical wine tasting: a session in a centuries-old underground Etruscan crypt, surrounded by history and some of Italy’s finest wines. Touted as a one-hour tasting, it’s hosted at the renowned Cantina del Brunello di Montalcino, which is one of Siena’s oldest wine shops. For about $143 per person, you’ll enjoy a curated selection of Tuscan classics like Brunello di Montalcino, Chianti Classico, and top Italian labels such as Sassicaia, Masseto, and Ornellaia—many of which are exclusive and not available for export. The tasting also includes a flavorful pairing of local pecorino cheeses and breadsticks, enhancing each sip with authentic flavors. Booking tends to fill up around 30 days in advance, which speaks to its popularity among discerning wine lovers.

What I appreciate most about this experience is the captivating location and the quality of wines offered. Drinking in a secret Etruscan crypt, dug into the tuff beneath Siena, creates an atmosphere that elevates the tasting far beyond a simple sip-and-swirl session. The other highlight: the expertly curated wine selection. From limited-edition bottles you can’t find elsewhere, to renowned labels like Masseto and Sassicaia, each pour feels carefully chosen to showcase Italy’s best. And the hosts—particularly Federico, the owner, and Esther, his knowledgeable sommelier—combine warmth with expertise, making the tasting both educational and fun.

However, one thing to keep in mind is that this experience is quite intimate, limited to a maximum of 10 travelers, which can be a plus or minus depending on your preference. Also, since transportation isn’t included, you’ll need to arrive at the starting point in Siena on your own. The one-hour duration is perfect for a quick yet meaningful encounter with Italian wines, but if you’re looking for a more extensive tour, you might want to combine it with other activities.

Key Points

• Unique setting: Drinking wine in a centuries-old Etruscan crypt is genuinely memorable.
• Premium wine selection: Offers top Tuscan and Italian labels, including limited-edition bottles.
• Authentic pairing: Local pecorino cheeses and breadsticks complement the tasting beautifully.
• Expert hosts: Federico and Esther bring knowledge and warmth, making the experience accessible and engaging.
• Limited group size: Small groups (up to 10) ensure personalized attention.
• Ideal for wine enthusiasts: Particularly those interested in Tuscan wines and authentic, atmospheric experiences.

An In-Depth Look at the Experience

The Setting: An Etruscan Crypt

Imagine descending into a dark, cool underground vault carved out of Siena’s soft tuff stone. This crypt, discovered during renovation work, has been turned into a private tasting space that combines history with indulgence. The atmosphere is undeniably special—the stone walls, faint flickering lights, and quiet ambiance wash over you as you settle in with a glass of wine. Several reviews mention “having a wine tasting in an Etruscan script,” emphasizing how unique and almost mystical the environment feels. It’s an encounter that elevates the simple act of drinking wine into a memorable event.

The Wine Selection

The shop itself is a treasure trove of Italian wines, with over a thousand labels, many exclusive and not for export, housed within the walls. Federico, the owner, spins tales of each bottle with passion, highlighting the rarity and significance of various labels. From Brunello di Montalcino to Chianti Classico and Supertuscans, the selection is carefully curated to showcase Tuscany’s finest. Several reviewers note that Federico’s expertise enhances the experience—one mentioned how he “taught us so much about wine,” making novices feel at ease while satisfying seasoned connoisseurs.

Food and Pairing

The tasting isn’t just about the wines; the accompanying cheeses are equally noteworthy. A selection of local pecorino cheeses is served alongside breadsticks, providing a savory counterpoint that intensifies the wine’s flavors. The cheeses come from the best local sources, adding an authentic Tuscan touch. Many guests comment on how the pairing amplifies the tasting, turning it into a sensory journey of taste and aroma.

The Hosts and Group Size

Federico and Esther—who holds a certified sommelier designation—bring a friendly and informative tone to the session. Several reviews highlight Esther’s enthusiasm and deep knowledge, adding a layer of educational value. The small group size (max 10) makes it feel intimate, allowing for questions and personalized attention, which many travelers find invaluable.

Practical Considerations

The tour lasts roughly one hour, an ideal length for a quick exploration without feeling rushed. Since transportation isn’t included, plan to arrive by yourself—it’s close to public transit, making access straightforward. The price of around $143 per person may seem high, but considering the rarity of the wines, the atmospheric setting, and expert guidance, it offers good value. You get a curated wine list, a memorable setting, and professional hosts, making it a worthwhile splurge for wine lovers.

Authenticity and Reviews

TripAdvisor reviews consistently praise Federico and Esther for their warmth and expertise. One guest even mentioned shipping a case home—a clear sign of their confidence in the quality and value of the wines. Many reviewers describe this as a highlight of their trip to Siena, with comments like “this was a highlight of our trip” and “an explosion of taste you won’t forget.” Such glowing reviews underscore the tour’s genuine appeal.

Who Would Love This Experience

This wine tasting is perfect for travelers who appreciate quality and authenticity. If you’re interested in learning more about Tuscan wines, especially Brunello or Chianti, or simply wish to enjoy a unique setting that combines history with gastronomy, you’ll find this experience rewarding. It’s ideal for small groups or couples looking for an intimate, educational, and atmospheric outing. If you prefer larger, more commercial tasting rooms, or need a tour with transport included, this might not suit your needs. But for those eager to explore Italy’s wine culture in a setting that feels both historic and exclusive, this promises an unforgettable moment.

Final Thoughts: Is It Worth It?

Certainly, at around $143, this isn’t the cheapest wine tasting in Tuscany, but the quality, atmosphere, and personalized attention justify the price. The tasting offers a taste of Tuscany’s best wines paired with local cheeses, all served in an underground setting that feels like stepping back in time. The hosts’ passion and expertise turn a simple wine sampling into a memorable cultural experience. If you love discovering hidden gems and are curious about Italy’s wine treasures, this is a superb choice.

Who It’s Best For

• Wine lovers eager to explore top Italian labels
• Travelers seeking authentic, atmospheric experiences
• Small groups or couples craving intimacy and personalized attention
• Those interested in Tuscany’s wine culture and local food pairing
• Visitors who appreciate a touch of history during their tasting
• Adventurous types wanting a memorable story to tell

FAQs

Is transportation included in this experience?
No, transportation isn’t provided. You’ll need to arrange your own way to the meeting point at Cantina del Brunello di Montalcino.

How long does the tasting last?
The tasting lasts approximately 1 hour, making it a perfect quick yet meaningful stop in Siena.

What wines are typically featured?
The selection includes the best Tuscan wines like Brunello di Montalcino, Chianti Classico, Supertuscan, and famous labels such as Masseto, Sassicaia, and Ornellaia.

Are the wines exclusive?
Yes, many bottles inside the shop are not exported and are produced in limited quantities, adding a special exclusivity to the tasting.

Is this suitable for beginners?
Absolutely. The hosts are welcoming and knowledgeable, making it a great introduction for novices, while still satisfying seasoned wine enthusiasts.

Can I buy wine after the tasting?
Yes, many guests choose to purchase bottles or even arrange for a shipment home, as one reviewer did.

This Siena wine tasting in an Etruscan crypt offers an unusual, enriching way to sample Italy’s best wines while soaking in a historic underground setting. It’s a must-try for lovers of good wine, history, and authentic experiences—an event that will surely linger in your memories long after you leave Tuscany.